Ramadan Meals Case Revived by 7th Cir.

  • Naira
  • January 14, 2016
  • 0 Comments
Spread the love

The Seventh Circuit revived a free exercise of religion case in which a Muslim inmate sued his jailers for interfering with his observance of Ramadan by withholding “special meals.”

The circuit vacated the lower court’s summary judgment in favor of the defendant. According to the court, making a prisoner choose between food and religion is a substantial burden on his free exercise.

Ramadan Behind Bars

Michael L. Thompson, 38, was and still is serving a life sentence in a Wisconsin jail. Thompson, an observant Muslim, sought to fast during the month of Ramadan. During Ramadan, the pious must not eat or drink between sun up and sun down. Thompson had been approved to receive “special meals” between the hours of daylight so that he could consume them during permitted hours.

Conflicting Facts

Allegedly, ten days into Ramadan, there was conflicting accounts of what happened next. Thompson claims that he was arbitrarily precluded from receiving at least one meal. An officer claimed that he stole one meal. Either way, Thompson was without food or drink for 55 hours and was left, during that time, with the choice of breaking his fast and resuming meals in the common cafeteria.

Food or Religion?

Thompson sued the guards under violations of the Free Exercise Clause. At the district level, he lost. The judge said that two days’ time without food was a de minimus burden on Thompson’s practice and that withholding a meal was justified punishment for his theft. Other theories of law he did not reach. The circuit vacated the district court’s ruling.

The circuit highlighted Nelson v. Miller, a 2009 case that stood for rule that government forcing a choice between religion and food was a substantial burden on the inmate’s free exercise of his religion — and applied it vigorously. Here, the circuit found, not only was the wait not de minimus, it was a 55 hour wait with the added anxiety that Thompson faced the possibility of not being admitted back onto the Ramadan list for special meals. Thus, this anxiety, even if it did not interfere with his peace and solitude, was a “substantial burden.”

Related Resources:


CNN
Facebook Comments Box
  • Related Posts

    Oil Prices Slide over Weak Demand Expectations
    • August 5, 2026

    Spread the love

    Spread the loveOil Prices Slide over Weak Demand Expectations In the global commodity market, crude oil prices trended on bearish note amidst uncertainties over demand outlook. The market prices of…

    Read more

    Continue reading
    China Keeps Benchmark Lending Rates Steady
    • August 5, 2026

    Spread the love

    Spread the loveChina Keeps Benchmark Lending Rates Steady China’s benchmark lending rates were kept unchanged, official data showed on Monday, in line with market expectations after key policy rates were…

    Read more

    Continue reading

    You Missed

    “Court Freezes Ise Kingdom Obaship Process In Lagos” — Bars Govt From Acting On Purported Oba-Elect Nomination

    • By admin
    • August 15, 2026
    • 7 views

    “Cambridge’s Youngest Black Professor Jason Arday Found Dead At 41” — Death Comes Days After Resignation Amid Plagiarism Allegations

    • By admin
    • August 15, 2026
    • 7 views

    “Suleja Crackdown: Police Arrest 139 Suspects, Arraign 64” — Recover Cutlasses, Knives, Live Cartridges

    • By admin
    • August 15, 2026
    • 6 views

    “Atiku, ADC Drag Tinubu To Federal High Court Over Alleged NYSC Certificate Forgery” — Seek Disqualification From 2027 Presidential Election

    • By admin
    • August 15, 2026
    • 8 views

    “Vandals Bring Down Five TCN Towers In Akwa Ibom, Seven More At Risk” — Ibom Power Left Without Supply As TCN Begins Emergency Repairs

    • By admin
    • August 15, 2026
    • 4 views

    “Anyone Who Is Making Money From Politics Is An Evil Person” — Melaye Says 90% Of Nigerian Politicians Have No Second Address

    • By admin
    • August 15, 2026
    • 5 views