Exasperated Judge Posner Kills Easement Dreams for Landowner

  • Naira
  • February 18, 2016
  • 0 Comments
Spread the love

Judge Posner, clearly exasperated by the procedural muck that was made out of a relatively routine easement case, killed the landowner’s dreams of establishing a prescriptive easement to a public road in the Seventh Circuit.

“The duration of this litigation,” he vented, is inexplicable and inexcusable — for it’s a pretty simple case!”

Easements

The case involved a landowner and the elements for valid easement for access to a public road. The plaintiff in question owned a parcel of 40 acres in Southwestern Indiana. Unfortunately, his land was completely surrounded by other landowners, cutting him off so there was no access to his land. He only gained ingress and exgress to and from his land because his neighbor who abutted his property to the north allowed him license to cross his land and gain access.

He filed a suit in 2001 to gain access to a main road which would have required him to cut through three plots of land immediately to his west. For reasons that befuddled the court, the case slogged through the justice system for 13 years before it finally got to the circuit.

Pretty Simple Indeed

Judge Posner’s frustration was justified: it is a simple case. The plaintiff sued under Indiana and federal law to establish that he had both a prescriptive easement and a claim for easement by necessity.

Experienced lawyers will see immediate issues here. First, the easement by necessity failed for the fact that it was clearly not necessary that the plaintiff have a new easement granted to the parcel in order to gain access — because he had access owing to the neighbor to the north. Easements by necessity are granted only if it is truly necessary to gain access to one’s land without breaking the law or trespass.

As for the prescriptive easement, there was a problem of title. The plaintiff contended that the heirs of the would-be burdened estates quitclaimed an easement to him. the problem is that other witnesses and owners of the other plots disputed this, and contended that the easement was actually sold to the Forest Service in 1967 — meaning there was nothing left to transfer to the plaintiff. And since a quitclaim carries with no guarantees of title, it was game over.

“And that’s it,” said judge Posner. Simple — right?

Related Resources:


CNN
Facebook Comments Box
  • Related Posts

    FG Reiterates Commitment to Sustainable Nutrition Activities
    • August 5, 2026

    Spread the love

    Spread the loveFG Reiterates Commitment to Sustainable Nutrition Activities The Federal Government has reiterated its commitment to promote sustainable nutrition activities in the country. Sen. Ibrahim Hadejia, Deputy Chief of…

    Read more

    Continue reading
    Digital Finance, Future of Young Consumers – FCCPC
    • August 5, 2026

    Spread the love

    Spread the loveDigital Finance, Future of Young Consumers – FCCPC The Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC) says an improved knowledge of digital finance will help young consumers position…

    Read more

    Continue reading

    You Missed

    “Court Freezes Ise Kingdom Obaship Process In Lagos” — Bars Govt From Acting On Purported Oba-Elect Nomination

    • By admin
    • August 15, 2026
    • 7 views

    “Cambridge’s Youngest Black Professor Jason Arday Found Dead At 41” — Death Comes Days After Resignation Amid Plagiarism Allegations

    • By admin
    • August 15, 2026
    • 7 views

    “Suleja Crackdown: Police Arrest 139 Suspects, Arraign 64” — Recover Cutlasses, Knives, Live Cartridges

    • By admin
    • August 15, 2026
    • 6 views

    “Atiku, ADC Drag Tinubu To Federal High Court Over Alleged NYSC Certificate Forgery” — Seek Disqualification From 2027 Presidential Election

    • By admin
    • August 15, 2026
    • 8 views

    “Vandals Bring Down Five TCN Towers In Akwa Ibom, Seven More At Risk” — Ibom Power Left Without Supply As TCN Begins Emergency Repairs

    • By admin
    • August 15, 2026
    • 4 views

    “Anyone Who Is Making Money From Politics Is An Evil Person” — Melaye Says 90% Of Nigerian Politicians Have No Second Address

    • By admin
    • August 15, 2026
    • 5 views