When the Department of State Services swooped down on many
suspected corrupt judges last year in a Gestapo style raid, many
Nigerians were quick to condemn the actions of the DSS as
“unconstitutional” and “illegal”. It was not until the
Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA 2015) was dissected at
the trial of Federal Republic of Nigeria v Justice
Ademola that it was discovered that the DSS acted within
the parameters of the law.
It is indeed an insult on the Council of Legal Education in
Nigeria for unenlightened Nigerians to be quick to brandish certain
actions as “illegal” and “unconstitutional” when host of
well-trained lawyers work in the advisory departments of such
government agencies that carry out such purported unconstitutional
acts.
The latest of such agencies to come under the foul cry of
engaging in such acts of unconstitutional illegality is none other
than the Nigerian Army, after it has received heavy backlash from
the peoples of South Eastern Nigeria for its engagement in
Operation Python Dance, which was intended to be nothing more than
a brazen “Show of force” by the Nigerian army; a warning to
impertinent agitators and trouble makers domiciled in certain
select states of the South Eastern region to “dey your
lane”. It was scheduled to be a fanciful display of the
massive strength of the Nigerian Army by having armoured tanks and
beautifully dressed soldiers parade the streets of the Rising Sun,
whilst the hospitable and educated inhabitants of the region smile,
wave and take photographs with the cute Nigerian soldiers to be
uploaded on Social Media sites.
However, after heavy emasculation of their otiose ego, and after
an assault of propagandist indoctrination by their “Supreme
Commander”, the self-styled Messiah of Biafraland, the hitherto
peaceful inhabitants of Abia and Rivers States of the South Eastern
Region suddenly decided that the Nigerian Army was in cahoots with
the Hausa populace to decimate them. The rest is history.
Many pro-Biafra agitators are quick to condemn the Operation
Python Dance as provocative, and unconstitutional. It is indeed
easy to make such sentimental statements, but what does the law
posit?
Section 217(2)(c) of the 1999 Constitution provides that “The
Federation shall, subject to an Act of the National Assembly made
in that behalf, equip and maintain the armed forces as may be
considered adequate and effective for the purpose of…. (c)
Suppressing insurrection and acting in aid of civil authorities to
restore order when called upon to do so by the president, but
subject to such conditions as may be prescribed by an Act of the
National Assembly”.
Suffice to say, the Act of the National Assembly referred to
here is the Armed Forces Act.
What then is the basis of the illegality of Operation Python
Dance as alleged by Pro-Biafra agitators? It has been submitted on
the behalf of the agitators that before the armed forces of the
Federal Republic can be deployed in accordance with Section 217
(2)(c) to maintain public order, the approval of the National
Assembly must first be sought and obtained. This contention is
highly fallacious and illogical. The role of the National Assembly
is limited to make laws for the regulation of the powers
exercisable by the President as Commander in Chief of the Armed
Forces of the Federation. This is by virtue of Section 218 (4) CFRN
1999 and they have already done this by enacting the Armed Forces
Act in 1994. Nowhere in the Armed Forces Act of Nigeria is it
stated that the powers of the Nigerian Army to maintain public
order as encapsulated in Section 217 (2) (c) CFRN is to be subject
to the approval and confirmation of the National Assembly.
However, it must be conceded that a careful study of Section 7
of the Armed Forces Act which provide that “The Chief of Defence
Staff shall, subject to the general direction of the
President and of the National Assembly, be vested
with the day-to-day command and general superintendence of the
Armed Forces” [emphasis mine] hint that the National Assembly is to
have a hand in directing the operations of the Armed Forces. It
should nevertheless not be forgotten that the Armed Forces Act is
made pursuant to the Constitution, which has empowered the National
Assembly in other instances to have control in directing the
affairs of the Armed Forces. Section 305 of the Constitution which
deals with Proclamation of a State of Emergency empowers both the
President and the National Assembly to have conjunctive powers in
declaring a state of emergency in any part of Nigeria. The
provisions of Section 217 of the Constitution should therefore not
be read together with that of Section 305 of the Constitution,
because both sections deal with entirely different scenarios. The
President never intended to declare a State of Emergency in any
part of the country when Operation Python Dance was planned, hence,
approval of the National Assembly was nothing but an unnecessary
surplusage.
It therefore behooves on this writer to propound, that any
submission that the requirements or conditions precedent for the
declaration of a state of emergency (As listed in Section 305 CFRN
and expounded by the Federal High Court and Court of Appeal in a
plethora of cases including the case of Plateau State of Nigeria
& Anor n. AGF (2006)3 NWLR (pt 967) 346 does not indeed apply
to Operation Python Dance, as it is not a state of emergency.
If the intellectual agitators do not therefore desist from such
unconstitutional arguments, and perform their legal obligations to
inform the violent and not-too-enlightened youths that the
activities of the Nigerian Army indeed has a legal and
constitutional coloration, and that if the IPOB agitators continue
in their insurrection, the hand of the Commander-in-Chief of the
Armed forces might just be forced into making an actual declaration
of a state of emergency in the troubled South Eastern Region.
@Legal Watchmen
I am Oluwanonso_Esq on Twitter.
When the Department of State Services swooped down on many
suspected corrupt judges last year in a Gestapo style raid, many
Nigerians were quick to condemn the actions of the DSS as
“unconstitutional” and “illegal”. It was not until the
Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA 2015) was dissected at
the trial of Federal Republic of Nigeria v Justice
Ademola that it was discovered that the DSS acted within
the parameters of the law.
It is indeed an insult on the Council of Legal Education in
Nigeria for unenlightened Nigerians to be quick to brandish certain
actions as “illegal” and “unconstitutional” when host of
well-trained lawyers work in the advisory departments of such
government agencies that carry out such purported unconstitutional
acts.
The latest of such agencies to come under the foul cry of
engaging in such acts of unconstitutional illegality is none other
than the Nigerian Army, after it has received heavy backlash from
the peoples of South Eastern Nigeria for its engagement in
Operation Python Dance, which was intended to be nothing more than
a brazen “Show of force” by the Nigerian army; a warning to
impertinent agitators and trouble makers domiciled in certain
select states of the South Eastern region to “dey your
lane”. It was scheduled to be a fanciful display of the
massive strength of the Nigerian Army by having armoured tanks and
beautifully dressed soldiers parade the streets of the Rising Sun,
whilst the hospitable and educated inhabitants of the region smile,
wave and take photographs with the cute Nigerian soldiers to be
uploaded on Social Media sites.
However, after heavy emasculation of their otiose ego, and after
an assault of propagandist indoctrination by their “Supreme
Commander”, the self-styled Messiah of Biafraland, the hitherto
peaceful inhabitants of Abia and Rivers States of the South Eastern
Region suddenly decided that the Nigerian Army was in cahoots with
the Hausa populace to decimate them. The rest is history.
Many pro-Biafra agitators are quick to condemn the Operation
Python Dance as provocative, and unconstitutional. It is indeed
easy to make such sentimental statements, but what does the law
posit?
Section 217(2)(c) of the 1999 Constitution provides that “The
Federation shall, subject to an Act of the National Assembly made
in that behalf, equip and maintain the armed forces as may be
considered adequate and effective for the purpose of…. (c)
Suppressing insurrection and acting in aid of civil authorities to
restore order when called upon to do so by the president, but
subject to such conditions as may be prescribed by an Act of the
National Assembly”.
Suffice to say, the Act of the National Assembly referred to
here is the Armed Forces Act.
What then is the basis of the illegality of Operation Python
Dance as alleged by Pro-Biafra agitators? It has been submitted on
the behalf of the agitators that before the armed forces of the
Federal Republic can be deployed in accordance with Section 217
(2)(c) to maintain public order, the approval of the National
Assembly must first be sought and obtained. This contention is
highly fallacious and illogical. The role of the National Assembly
is limited to make laws for the regulation of the powers
exercisable by the President as Commander in Chief of the Armed
Forces of the Federation. This is by virtue of Section 218 (4) CFRN
1999 and they have already done this by enacting the Armed Forces
Act in 1994. Nowhere in the Armed Forces Act of Nigeria is it
stated that the powers of the Nigerian Army to maintain public
order as encapsulated in Section 217 (2) (c) CFRN is to be subject
to the approval and confirmation of the National Assembly.
However, it must be conceded that a careful study of Section 7
of the Armed Forces Act which provide that “The Chief of Defence
Staff shall, subject to the general direction of the
President and of the National Assembly, be vested
with the day-to-day command and general superintendence of the
Armed Forces” [emphasis mine] hint that the National Assembly is to
have a hand in directing the operations of the Armed Forces. It
should nevertheless not be forgotten that the Armed Forces Act is
made pursuant to the Constitution, which has empowered the National
Assembly in other instances to have control in directing the
affairs of the Armed Forces. Section 305 of the Constitution which
deals with Proclamation of a State of Emergency empowers both the
President and the National Assembly to have conjunctive powers in
declaring a state of emergency in any part of Nigeria. The
provisions of Section 217 of the Constitution should therefore not
be read together with that of Section 305 of the Constitution,
because both sections deal with entirely different scenarios. The
President never intended to declare a State of Emergency in any
part of the country when Operation Python Dance was planned, hence,
approval of the National Assembly was nothing but an unnecessary
surplusage.
It therefore behooves on this writer to propound, that any
submission that the requirements or conditions precedent for the
declaration of a state of emergency (As listed in Section 305 CFRN
and expounded by the Federal High Court and Court of Appeal in a
plethora of cases including the case of Plateau State of Nigeria
& Anor n. AGF (2006)3 NWLR (pt 967) 346 does not indeed apply
to Operation Python Dance, as it is not a state of emergency.
If the intellectual agitators do not therefore desist from such
unconstitutional arguments, and perform their legal obligations to
inform the violent and not-too-enlightened youths that the
activities of the Nigerian Army indeed has a legal and
constitutional coloration, and that if the IPOB agitators continue
in their insurrection, the hand of the Commander-in-Chief of the
Armed forces might just be forced into making an actual declaration
of a state of emergency in the troubled South Eastern Region.
@Legal Watchmen
I am Oluwanonso_Esq on Twitter.
Read more https://nairalaw.com/the-legality-of-operation-python-dancel/