The Court System, Another SARS

By Sesugh Akume

After years of outcries and calls for the notorious Special
Anti-robbery Squad (SARS) to be scrapped, with the rogue outfit
purportedly shut down for the fourth time this year, a final
showdown weeks ago brought matters to ahead leading to the
fatalities of scores with the murder of unarmed, organised, civil
protesters at the Lekki tollgate on 20 October 2020.

SARS (which is still lowkey operational, not entirely scrapped
as claimed) is a metaphor for Nigeria’s dysfunction characterised
by bad governance, gross impunity and lawlessness,
unprofessionalism and incompetence, unbridled corruption, low IQ
and mental retardation, and everything one would never expect of a
police unit, much less the policing system of any real country.
Sadly, this is what the court system in Nigeria is, save for the
physical murder, arbitrary arrests and illegal detention, extortion
at gun point, etc. But in effect, it is actually the same, if not
worse.

The Nigerian court system is slow, archaic, and certainly not
designed or intended for the everyday Nigerian. It is more a court
of law than a court of justice.

It is expensive and not accessible. Aside from having to pay for
the services of lawyers, everything else is paid for, both for
legitimate and under-the-table payments, even for things ordered by
the court itself. The other day, at the Federal High Court, Abuja
after a matter was adjourned and the court ordered for a hearing
notice to be served to the other parties notify them of the new
date, demands were made both to get the hearing notice and to
‘mobilise’ the bailiff to serve it. Asking for money for a hearing
notice to be issued (forms already provided, all the officials do
is to fill them) was a new low.

This is an insensitive, insular system where court registrars
would not deign to send simple 4 naira text messages to reschedule
court sittings. Lawyers (senior advocates inclusive) travel all the
way, including from out of town (along with the associated costs)
only to be told that the court wouldn’t be sitting! Changes in plan
that are usually not emergencies or impromptu but known well
ahead.

There are all manner of dirty extortionary practices one would
least expect from a Temple of Justice. The officials there
don’think so. The court is to them just like any other place
hustlers use as their grounds to earn a buck. They see nothing
sacred about it. It’s normal. A complaint I wrote to the chief
registrar of the Federal High Court on corrupt practices I
witnessed at the Federal High Court Makurdi, which are in clear
breach of what the court itself has made public, since 7 October,
hasn’t as much as been acknowledged. I wrote again in reminder and
to complain about it a month later, nothing came of it. If my hands
weren’t full at this time, the impunity of the chief registrar,
Emmanuel Gakko, would have been addressed. But it’s never too
late.

I was shocked to a stupour when confronted with the reality at
close range, of the Supreme Court of Nigeria, the highest court in
the land, which has absolutely no regard for the laws of the land.
I made a Freedom of Information (FOI) application to know the
status of Martins Alo v Speaker, Ondo House of Assembly, filed
since 2018, and got no response at all, whereas the law says it
must answered in 3 days or at worst 7 days. Two weeks later I wrote
a reminder/complaint letter, again to no avail, eliciting may
lawsuit against the Supreme Court and the chief registrar,
Hadizatu

Mustapha (FHC/ABJ/CS/1161/2020). No lessons were learnt when I
again, made an FOI request on the status of Andrew Osakue v
EDOCASA, also filed since 2018, leading to a second lawsuit
(FHC/ABJ/CS/1491/2020).

Both are landmark cases challenging the impunity of subnational
(state and local) governments denying the people access to public
records of their own government. These have not been attended to
since 2018, but elitist cases commenced at the lower courts began a
year later have gone all the way to the Supreme Court and
determined. What does it says about the system?

When I eventually got the replies all I could do was shake my
head. The Court there is no uniform standard for referencing its
letters, the dispatch date on one of them is a wrong one, they even
start sentences with small letters, and others blunders too
embarrassing to say. And this is supposed to be the highest court
in the land!

Space limits me from going into the practice and conduct of
judges that rather tend to hamper the course of justice. Or the
system’s deliberate resistance to adopting technology to ease the
work and make it more efficient, therefore more timely (as justice
delayed is justice denied). Or the seeming disposition of judges
waiting for government lawyers to say any foolish thing at all so
that they would rule in their favour.

There are institutions set up to regulate society and make it
liveable for us all. Leading this category, in my view, is the
court system. It is intended to be the last hope of the ‘common
man’, but in Nigeria it isn’t so in practical terms. Social media
seems the last hope of the everyday citizen. In fact, I’ve seen
where the police took to Twitter to report the army! Government
officials and agencies have been on each other’s necks repeatedly
on social media. It appears social media isn’t the last resort of
the everyday person alone. It shouldn’t be so. This dysfunction
won’t last forever. Something must eventually give.

Like Omoyele Sowore or not, like #RevolutionNow or not, it will
come. The question is how do we prefer it? In 1962, John F.
Kennedy, the 35th US president, famously said, ‘Those who make
peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution
inevitable.’ It’s either the court system and entire law
enforcement and justice system reforms itself into a decent sector
that offers equity, justice, and fairness; real value and timely,
or continues being rogue. When the consequences come some day, and
they will, none of us will like the outcome.

Sesugh Akume, a public policy analyst wrote
from Abuja. He tweets @sesugh_akume, and
can be reached via
sesugh.akume@gmail.com.

By Sesugh Akume

After years of outcries and calls for the notorious Special
Anti-robbery Squad (SARS) to be scrapped, with the rogue outfit
purportedly shut down for the fourth time this year, a final
showdown weeks ago brought matters to ahead leading to the
fatalities of scores with the murder of unarmed, organised, civil
protesters at the Lekki tollgate on 20 October 2020.

SARS (which is still lowkey operational, not entirely scrapped
as claimed) is a metaphor for Nigeria’s dysfunction characterised
by bad governance, gross impunity and lawlessness,
unprofessionalism and incompetence, unbridled corruption, low IQ
and mental retardation, and everything one would never expect of a
police unit, much less the policing system of any real country.
Sadly, this is what the court system in Nigeria is, save for the
physical murder, arbitrary arrests and illegal detention, extortion
at gun point, etc. But in effect, it is actually the same, if not
worse.

The Nigerian court system is slow, archaic, and certainly not
designed or intended for the everyday Nigerian. It is more a court
of law than a court of justice.

It is expensive and not accessible. Aside from having to pay for
the services of lawyers, everything else is paid for, both for
legitimate and under-the-table payments, even for things ordered by
the court itself. The other day, at the Federal High Court, Abuja
after a matter was adjourned and the court ordered for a hearing
notice to be served to the other parties notify them of the new
date, demands were made both to get the hearing notice and to
‘mobilise’ the bailiff to serve it. Asking for money for a hearing
notice to be issued (forms already provided, all the officials do
is to fill them) was a new low.

This is an insensitive, insular system where court registrars
would not deign to send simple 4 naira text messages to reschedule
court sittings. Lawyers (senior advocates inclusive) travel all the
way, including from out of town (along with the associated costs)
only to be told that the court wouldn’t be sitting! Changes in plan
that are usually not emergencies or impromptu but known well
ahead.

There are all manner of dirty extortionary practices one would
least expect from a Temple of Justice. The officials there
don’think so. The court is to them just like any other place
hustlers use as their grounds to earn a buck. They see nothing
sacred about it. It’s normal. A complaint I wrote to the chief
registrar of the Federal High Court on corrupt practices I
witnessed at the Federal High Court Makurdi, which are in clear
breach of what the court itself has made public, since 7 October,
hasn’t as much as been acknowledged. I wrote again in reminder and
to complain about it a month later, nothing came of it. If my hands
weren’t full at this time, the impunity of the chief registrar,
Emmanuel Gakko, would have been addressed. But it’s never too
late.

I was shocked to a stupour when confronted with the reality at
close range, of the Supreme Court of Nigeria, the highest court in
the land, which has absolutely no regard for the laws of the land.
I made a Freedom of Information (FOI) application to know the
status of Martins Alo v Speaker, Ondo House of Assembly, filed
since 2018, and got no response at all, whereas the law says it
must answered in 3 days or at worst 7 days. Two weeks later I wrote
a reminder/complaint letter, again to no avail, eliciting may
lawsuit against the Supreme Court and the chief registrar,
Hadizatu

Mustapha (FHC/ABJ/CS/1161/2020). No lessons were learnt when I
again, made an FOI request on the status of Andrew Osakue v
EDOCASA, also filed since 2018, leading to a second lawsuit
(FHC/ABJ/CS/1491/2020).

Both are landmark cases challenging the impunity of subnational
(state and local) governments denying the people access to public
records of their own government. These have not been attended to
since 2018, but elitist cases commenced at the lower courts began a
year later have gone all the way to the Supreme Court and
determined. What does it says about the system?

When I eventually got the replies all I could do was shake my
head. The Court there is no uniform standard for referencing its
letters, the dispatch date on one of them is a wrong one, they even
start sentences with small letters, and others blunders too
embarrassing to say. And this is supposed to be the highest court
in the land!

Space limits me from going into the practice and conduct of
judges that rather tend to hamper the course of justice. Or the
system’s deliberate resistance to adopting technology to ease the
work and make it more efficient, therefore more timely (as justice
delayed is justice denied). Or the seeming disposition of judges
waiting for government lawyers to say any foolish thing at all so
that they would rule in their favour.

There are institutions set up to regulate society and make it
liveable for us all. Leading this category, in my view, is the
court system. It is intended to be the last hope of the ‘common
man’, but in Nigeria it isn’t so in practical terms. Social media
seems the last hope of the everyday citizen. In fact, I’ve seen
where the police took to Twitter to report the army! Government
officials and agencies have been on each other’s necks repeatedly
on social media. It appears social media isn’t the last resort of
the everyday person alone. It shouldn’t be so. This dysfunction
won’t last forever. Something must eventually give.

Like Omoyele Sowore or not, like #RevolutionNow or not, it will
come. The question is how do we prefer it? In 1962, John F.
Kennedy, the 35th US president, famously said, ‘Those who make
peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution
inevitable.’ It’s either the court system and entire law
enforcement and justice system reforms itself into a decent sector
that offers equity, justice, and fairness; real value and timely,
or continues being rogue. When the consequences come some day, and
they will, none of us will like the outcome.

Sesugh Akume, a public policy analyst wrote
from Abuja. He tweets @sesugh_akume, and
can be reached via
sesugh.akume@gmail.com.